'Not AI's To Take': First Nations stories at centre of fight over artificial intelligence scraping

Phoebe Solon
Phoebe Solon Published November 20, 2026 at 2.00pm (AWST)

As Australia's creative industries campaign against the unauthorised use of copyrighted works to train artificial intelligence, First Nations advocates warn existing laws fail to protect the cultural knowledge and stories being fed into commercial systems.

A national campaign calling on the Federal Government to protect Australian creative works from unauthorised artificial intelligence (AI) training has brought renewed attention to the scraping of Indigenous stories and cultural knowledge without consent.

Not AI's To Take launched on November 18, with artists Jack River, Dobby, Josh Pyke and KLP speaking at the ARIA Awards. A pre-recorded message from Sir Elton John also featured, while prominent supporters include Jimmy Barnes, Paul Kelly, Peter Garrett and Ben Lee.

The campaign is urging the Government to maintain strong copyright protections and reject arrangements allowing AI developers to use creative works without permission or payment.

But for First Nations creators, the issue goes beyond copyright and remuneration.

It concerns cultural authority, Indigenous ownership and communities' rights to determine how their knowledge and stories are used.

The issue has come into sharp focus after Broome-based Magabala Books revealed 37 of its titles had been scraped from an online archive of pirated books and used by Meta to train its AI systems.

Speaking with National Indigenous Times, Magabala Books chief executive Lilly Brown said the discovery left authors feeling betrayed.

"These books are treasures," Ms Brown said.

"These people have put their heart and soul as creators ... creating these stories and these books that hold really significant cultural knowledge related to place."

Ms Brown said the experience felt like someone had "entered a person's home and stolen a treasured possession without permission or payment".

She said creators faced significant barriers to seeking justice, including the cost of legal action and difficulties holding multinational technology companies accountable.

"There's currently no legislation to support creators, to hold some of these multinational companies to account," she said.

Ms Brown said Indigenous stories were deeply connected to Country, language and community, something conventional copyright protections did not adequately recognise.

"These stories are so connected to place and people, and language, and are so held in the fabric of community," she said.

"And yet AI has no place. ... It's so anti-relational."

She said the unauthorised use of First Nations material risked repeating a history of cultural appropriation and the theft and suppression of Indigenous knowledge.

"ICIP exists to protect that. It exists to counter that process," Ms Brown said.

Australia does not currently have standalone legislation specifically protecting Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property (ICIP), despite long standing advocacy.

Ms Brown said the absence of protections was particularly concerning as governments developed frameworks to regulate AI.

Solicitor and ICIP specialist Dr Terri Janke, a Wuthathi, Yadhaigana and Meriam woman, said the campaign's calls for permission and agreed payment were important but insufficient for First Nations cultural material.

"Copyright generally protects original works created by identifiable individuals and fixed in material form. However, much Indigenous cultural expression is communal, intergenerational and passed down through oral traditions and cultural practice," she said.

"Dreaming stories, language, traditional artistic styles and clan designs may therefore fall outside conventional copyright protections.

"Where traditional knowledge is recorded, copyright can belong to the person who documented it rather than the community from which it originated.

"I support licensing, but a licensing scheme needs to be about more than an economic exchange.

"For First Nations works, cultural integrity and attribution are also important."

Dr Janke said secret or sacred knowledge should not be used to train AI systems, and that cultural authority and context must determine whether material can be shared.

She called for mandatory transparency requirements requiring AI developers to disclose their training data sources and consider Indigenous cultural protocols and consent processes.

"Standalone ICIP legislation should recognise communities' rights to maintain, protect and develop their cultures, consistent with Article 31 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples," she said.

"It should also provide protection against offensive or demeaning uses, ensure attribution, recognise cultural authority and allow communities to seek redress where large-scale use causes cultural harm."

A spokesperson for the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts said the Government to the publication, that it recognised concerns about copyrighted material being used to train AI, particularly among First Nations creators.

"The Government's clear position is that Australian creators must retain ownership and control of their work, including control of the price and value," the spokesperson said.

The Government said it remained committed through its National Cultural Policy, Revive, to working with First Nations peoples on standalone legislation protecting traditional knowledge and traditional cultural expressions.

The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Expert Working Group is developing its final advice on a preferred model for ICIP legislation, expected in early December 2026.

The department said measures addressing fake Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander art and merchandise were being progressed alongside broader ICIP protections.

Dr Janke said artists and art centres could meanwhile use existing copyright and consumer protection laws to challenge some unauthorised uses.

She also recommended clearly stating on websites that material must not be used for AI training.

However, Dr Janke questioned why individual artists and often under-resourced art centres should carry the responsibility of opting out.

"The onus should not be on art centres and artists to opt out. It should be on AI developers," she said.

Ms Brown said getting protections right for Indigenous cultural material could benefit the entire creative sector.

"If the industry can get right what it's doing in relation to Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property, then all creators will benefit," she said.

For First Nations communities, she said, the stakes extended beyond lost income to the protection of stories, languages and knowledge carrying generations of cultural responsibility.

National Indigenous Times has contacted Meta for comment.

   Related   

   Phoebe Solon   

Download our App

@natindigtimes
Article Audio

Disclaimer: This function is AI-generated and therefore may mispronounce.

National Indigenous Times

Disclaimer: This function is AI-generated and therefore may mispronounce.