Government dodges question on whether it is 'embarrassed' by UN report on Indigenous rights

Dechlan Brennan
Dechlan Brennan Published November 20, 2026 at 11.00am (AWST)

The federal government has declined to say whether it is "embarrassed" by a scathing United Nations report on Australia's human rights record in a testy parliamentary exchange.

Last week, the UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples concluded his visit to Australia by arguing that the "protection of Indigenous peoples' rights" in the country is a "bit embarrassing".

The Commonwealth government "need to step in" and "take its responsibility," Dr Albert K. Barume said, citing the over-incarceration of First Peoples, the disproportionate rate of child removals and the continued shackling of women giving birth in prison.

"If it decides to outsource the delivery of those rights to states and territories, that's up to it," he told National Indigenous Times. "But then it should set those minimum standards that are mandatory, but also ensure accountability on human rights."

Dr Barume will deliver his full report in September next year.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by SBS News (@sbsnews_au)

In the Senate this week, Foreign Minister Penny Wong was asked by Senator Lidia Thorpe whether the government was "embarrassed" by the state of human rights protections for First Peoples following Dr Barume's comments.

"I know that Dr Barume made initial comments, but we obviously wish to read his complete report, which will be presented to the Human Rights Council in September," Senator Wong said.

Noting that Dr Barume had met with the Minister for Indigenous Australians, she added: "We do acknowledge the concerns raised. As you know...the human rights framework in this country involves both state and federal laws as well as the common law and the Constitution."

When Senator Thorpe asked whether, in light of Dr Barume's comments, Australia deserved a seat on the United Nations Security Council, Senator Wong replied: "It's a matter for you as a member of this chamber elected by the Australian people if you choose to not support Australia's campaign and aspiration."

After Senator Thorpe interjected, saying she would "campaign against it," Senator Wong added: "Perhaps you could campaign for Iran or some other country like that."

She later withdrew the comment.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Northern Land Council (@northernlandcouncil)

Governments across the country, both Labor and Liberal, have faced criticism from human rights groups for introducing laws that undermine the Closing the Gap agreement.

The federal government has repeatedly refused to intervene in state and territory criminal justice systems, arguing it lacks the constitutional authority, despite receiving legal advice that it can act in some areas under its international human rights obligations.

Dr Barume told reporters last week that state and territory governments were not the bodies held accountable under international law.

"If you cannot be subjected to international scrutiny, you should not be in charge of human rights," he argued. "The Commonwealth government is the state responsible for international human rights standards in Australia.

"Human rights are not domestic issues. Human rights are international issues...and the standards are internationally set."

   Related   

   Dechlan Brennan   

Download our App

@natindigtimes
Article Audio

Disclaimer: This function is AI-generated and therefore may mispronounce.

National Indigenous Times

Disclaimer: This function is AI-generated and therefore may mispronounce.