Jobs Events Advertise Newsletter

Experts knock out Mundine's belief Voice will make him British

Mikele Syron -

WHAT WAS CLAIMED

Indigenous people will become British subjects if the 'yes' vote succeeds at the voice referendum.

OUR VERDICT

False. The referendum's outcome will have no bearing on the citizenship of any Australians.

Former boxing champ and NRL star Anthony Mundine claims Indigenous people will become British subjects if the 'yes' vote succeeds at the voice referendum.

This is false. Experts told AAP FactCheck the referendum's outcome would not change the nationality of Indigenous people in Australia.

The proposed constitutional amendment would recognise Indigenous people in the nation's founding document and pave the way for establishing an advisory body of Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander people to parliament and the executive.

It would not affect any Australian laws relating to citizenship or nationality.

Mundine made the claim in an Instagram video shared with more than 30,000 followers.

A screenshot from the Instagram video.

Anthony Mundine is spreading misinformation on social media.

"Why do we need a voice? We've got sisters and brothers in parliament already … that can act on our behalf and they do it right. Why are they pushing so hard now?" Mundine asks in the video.

"Because they want to get us in the constitution to where we become British subjects and under their … regime and then when that happens, and we have no sovereignty of the land."

It is not clear what evidence his claim is based on, given the referendum would have no impact on citizenship.

Australian citizens were once legally defined as 'British subjects' under Section 7 of the 1948 Citizenship and Nationality Act.

That status ceased after the passing of the 1984 Citizenship Amendment Act in Australia.

The UK government still defines 'British subject' as a legal type of British nationality, though this is a narrow legal definition.

An Australian citizenship document (file image)

There is no link between the voice proposal and citizenship.

Experts told AAP FactCheck the proposed amendment being presented at the referendum makes no mention of citizenship or nationality and would have no effect on laws regarding those issues.

Dr Sangeetha Pillai, a citizenship law expert at UNSW Sydney, said a successful 'yes' vote would not alter the nationality of any Indigenous individual or Indigenous people collectively.

"The only thing that a 'yes' outcome in the referendum will do is require Parliament to establish an advisory body called the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice," Dr Pillai told AAP FactCheck.

Professor Melissa Castan, a law professor at Monash University, agreed, saying a successful referendum would recognise Indigenous people as the first peoples of Australia and establish an advisory body to parliament.

"No Indigenous person will become a British citizen if yes succeeds at the referendum," Prof Castan told AAP FactCheck.

Aboriginal dancers perform during a citizenship ceremony (file image)

Indigenous people will remain Australians after the referendum.

Dr Rayner Thwaites, a citizenship law expert at the University of Sydney, also said the claim was false.

"Australia's independence from Britain is not reversible at this point in our history," Dr Rayner said.

"There is nothing in the proposed voice; the constitutional amendment being put to referendum this October, that would change the legal nationality of Indigenous people to British subject," he told AAP FactCheck.

Professor Gabrielle Appleby, a law professor at UNSW Sydney, also knocked down Mundine's claim.

"The proposed constitutional amendment will not affect the status of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in relation to their citizenship or the High Court's confirmation of their status as having a unique connection and belonging to the land that is now Australia," Professor Appleby told AAP FactCheck.

"Constitutional and international law experts have also indicated that the proposed constitutional amendment does not speak to or affect the legal position relating to and ongoing assertion of First Nations sovereignty in Australia."

THE VERDICT

The claim Indigenous people will become British subjects if the 'yes' vote succeeds in the voice referendum is false.

Experts told AAP FactCheck the referendum would have no impact on the nationality or citizenship of Indigenous people.

False — The claim is inaccurate.

Mikele Syron - AAP FactCheck

   Related   

Yes campaign surplus under microscope
Recently released data from the Australian Electoral Commission has revealed lea...
Dechlan Brennan 4 Apr 2024
Third South Australian council drops Acknowledgement of Country
Naracoorte Lucindale Council has removed an Acknowledgement of Country from its...
Giovanni Torre 4 Mar 2024
Warren Mundine, SBS set to meet over biased Voice interview
A demand from Warren Mundine to meet with SBS following a Voice referendum night...
Callan Morse 12 Feb 2024
Rapper Briggs talks down to a Storm in an Indigenous Voice
New disclosures from the Australian Electoral Commission has revealed that a boa...
Andrew Mathieson 5 Feb 2024

   Mikele Syron   

Martin Gabor 20 May 2024
Ah Chee next Linc in chain as Lions rebuild
Chris Fagan didn't forget Callum Ah Chee's gentle pre-season reminder when Lin...
Murray Wenzel 20 May 2024
Maroons boost as top gear Hammer speeds towards Origin
Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow is back to top speed after a hamstring strain and says he's...
Joe Gould 20 May 2024
From footy clinics to 50k fans: Braidon Burns is back
Three weeks ago, he was running footy clinics for school kids but Braidon Burns...
Jasper Bruce 20 May 2024