Blaming Don Punch alone misses the crux of Western Australia's problem

Zak Kirkup Published November 19, 2026 at 5.45pm (AWST)

In July 2022, three Aboriginal children were killed by their mother in Port Hedland. The day before, she had been turned away from a women's refuge. Police, housing officials and the children's own grandmother had raised the alarm. Last month, it was announced an inquest would be held into the deaths.

Four years on, with fresh reports of children at risk across the Pilbara, the focus has fallen on one man: Western Australia's Aboriginal Affairs Minister Don Punch.

I'll be very, very clear up front: Don Punch is no friend of mine. I have zero interest in defending him - but blaming him alone misses the crux of the problem our state faces.

The case against the minister

Opposition Leader Basil Zempilas has called for Mr Punch to be sacked and launched a parliamentary petition, with Dr Robert Isaacs AM, an Aboriginal Elder and one of the great leaders of this state, as its principal petitioner. Basil deserves real credit, for it has been a long time since I have seen an Opposition leader push this hard on an issue that touches Aboriginal people alone. There are no easy votes in it, and that speaks to his character. The reality is that Don Punch is not a good communicator - telling the media that your portfolio has no direct responsibility for housing, health or child protection was never going to land well.

Uncomfortably, though, he was right. That is the real problem.

Minister without a department

In WA, the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs is not, to quote a Labor MP and friend, "an implementer". At best, he is an advocate. The old Department of Aboriginal Affairs was broken apart, its functions spread between Premier and Cabinet and units inside agencies like health and education.

So the minister answers at Cabinet for outcomes he does not control, with no department to deliver them. Whether it was Don Punch or Fred Chaney in the role, the constraint would be the same. When Punch says child protection isn't his responsibility, he offers it as a defence but in reality it is really an indictment of how the job has been built.

Money in the right places

The answer is not more government; as a Liberal, I fear any response that starts there. Refreshingly, Child Protection Minister Jessica Stojkovski has put intense focus on Aboriginal community-controlled organisations being in charge of Aboriginal service delivery, backed by a $37.7 million Budget expansion. That is the right money going to the right place.

But someone inside government still needs the authority to hold agencies to account. If the portfolio is to mean anything, its minister needs legitimate authority: sight of how every agency spends its Aboriginal funding, and the standing to call agencies - and Cabinet colleagues - out when they fail. Otherwise we will keep swapping ministers and getting the same results.

Who holds the role matters too.

Cabinet Secretary Divina D'Anna, the Member for Kimberley and a Yawuru, Nimanburr and Bardi woman, is a capable, respected MP who you would instinctively think should hold it. I suspect one day she will. But the job as currently built would constrain her too.

Dorothy Papertalk fought for years for an inquest to be held into the deaths of her grandchildren. Image: The Australian.

We are blessed in our leaders

East Coast readers might see the rise of One Nation and assume racism has found a new home in our Parliament. That could not be further from the truth. Secret Harbour's new member, Luke Herdegen, made a point of acknowledging the first Australians in his first address, and One Nation's state leader, Rod Caddies, spent 15 years in child protection and has a deep understanding of service delivery in regional WA.

The same goes across the chamber. Premier Roger Cook, I genuinely believe, wants to right many of the wrongs of our history. Former Premier Colin Barnett never treated Aboriginal affairs as somebody else's problem, and took strides to create the South West Native Title Settlement, in effect WA's first treaty.

Yet in the Pilbara and the Goldfields, which deliver billions to this state and the Commonwealth, the people whose land is mined live in some of the worst conditions in our country. If this were happening to children in our suburbs, the response would be overwhelming. Because it happens on faraway country, we look away.

The failing is on all of us

In February, the Honourable Ken Wyatt AM becomes the first Aboriginal Governor in our state's history, and in 2029 we mark 200 years since British settlement. It is a fitting moment to reflect on how far we have come, and how much is left to do.

Generations of injustice cannot be overcome in one term of government, nor by one man. The expectation is on all of us, each and every day, not just on 26 January, in NAIDOC Week or in Reconciliation Week.

Otherwise we are no better than the crowd at the Melbourne Cup, who only care about horse welfare on that one day. We wear the wristband, share the LinkedIn post, and then blame those who are trying their hardest for the failings of us all.

It is time for the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs to be given real authority, for without it, things will never change.

Zak Kirkup, of Yamatji heritage, is the former WA Liberal Party Leader and one of the largest employers of Aboriginal people in WA.

   Related   

   Zak Kirkup   

Download our App

@natindigtimes
Article Audio

Disclaimer: This function is AI-generated and therefore may mispronounce.

National Indigenous Times

Disclaimer: This function is AI-generated and therefore may mispronounce.