Children and young people in South Australian care and youth detention are being denied fundamental rights, a new report argues, with many reporting feeling unsafe, unheard and disconnected from loved ones.
The Guardian for Children and Young People — the state's independent oversight body — received 661 advocacy requests relating to children and young people in out-of-home care (OOHC) during 2025-26, most of which came directly from children themselves.
"Children and young people in OOHC have a fundamental right to be safe and well cared for. Yet this was the right most frequently interrupted across our advocacy work, annual review audits and residential care visits," the report said.
"Children and young people consistently told us that safety, stable relationships, meaningful participation and connection to important people in their lives were not routinely afforded to them."
Children missing out on fundamental rights
A further 633 requests related to young people in youth detention, also mostly initiated by the young people themselves.
"Particular attention was paid to rights impacts for Aboriginal children and young people," the report states, "who continue to experience disproportionate and pervasive overrepresentation in youth detention and OOHC".
Indigenous children in South Australia are placed in OOHC at the second-highest rate in the country. However, the state has one of the lowest rates of youth detention for First Nations children and young people — below the national average.
Acting Guardian Sue Macdonald said children entering care had a right to safe, stable and supported living arrangements, but too many continued to experience instability and uncertainty.
"When a child reaches out to our office because every other avenue has failed them, we need to ask why the system did not respond sooner because being safe, having a voice and maintaining important relationships are fundamental rights, not privileges," Ms Macdonald said.
Failing children in care
Aboriginal children accounted for 38 per cent of those in OOHC at the end of the financial year, despite making up less than 6 per cent of the youth population.
The report noted: "South Australia has seen a worsening of the rate of Aboriginal children and young people in OOHC in 2026, which reflects broader social inequalities specific to South Australia."
Aboriginal children and young people also experienced a higher rate of significant incidents in care, with 40 per cent of all people in OOHC who experienced a significant incident during 2025-26 identified as Indigenous.
"This tells us that Aboriginal children are not only more likely to be in care but are also disproportionately represented among those experiencing serious events," the report said.
The report identifies the right to feel safe and well cared for, the right to be listened to and have a say in decision-making, and the right to maintain contact with important people as the three most frequently raised concerns among children in OOHC.
Together, the concerns accounted for almost 70 per cent of all issues raised with the out-of-home care advocacy team.
Children and young people told advocates they "feel neglected by the system", that they "miss being a big sister" and that they're "scared to sleep" in their placements.
"Children should not have to fight the system to feel safe in the place they are living," Ms Macdonald said. "They should not have to repeatedly tell adults that they are scared, unheard or disconnected from the people they love."
Concerns over continued youth detention
While the rate of youth detention is below the national average, the report raises concerns about the continued detention of children under 14. As in the rest of the country, many of the children and young people behind bars have spent extended periods on remand.
The South Australian Law Reform Institute has recently begun consulting on potential bail reforms, with the Guardian warning that further restrictions on access to bail could increase the number of children held in detention.
This would place additional pressure on young people and staff at the Adelaide Youth Training Centre, Ms Macdonald said.
"When almost 43 per cent of children return to detention within 12 months, we have to be honest about what is and isn't working," she argued.
"Rather than spending enormous amounts of time and money into doing what doesn't work, I call on the South Australian government to change its approach and invest in programs that...address the structural inequities leading to youth crime and disadvantage for many children and young people in this state."