Both major parties in Victoria are engaging in a race to the bottom on youth crime, advocates say, with a Liberal Party plan for a bootcamp for youth offenders criticised as "dehumanising".
On Sunday, the Victorian Liberals, who are on track for an election victory in a fortnight, announced a policy — based on Queensland's 'Circuit Breaker' program — which will see young offenders placed in a bootcamp and taught "discipline, respect and the value of hard work".
"Our tough new bootcamps will instil the discipline and respect lacking in so many young offenders and give them the skills they need to get on the right path," opposition leader Jess Wilson said.
Under the proposed policy, courts will be able to send offenders aged 14 to 17 to the bootcamp instead of issuing a community corrections order or sending them to prison. The camp will be established on the site of the former Dhurringile Prison, a former POW camp which closed as a minimum-security prison in 2024.
"At our bootcamp there will be no soft options, no sitting around and no getting out of the hard work," shadow police minister Brad Battin said.
Crime is seen as a key factor in the election, with polling regularly citing it as a major concern for voters.
However, advocates argue "punitive" and jail-based solutions, rather than rehabilitative programs, will fail to make the community safer in the long term.
Responding to the Liberals' pre-election policy commitment, the Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service (VALS) said the party had chosen to embrace incarceration and punishment, rather than demonstrate an openness to evidence-based, culturally grounded and Aboriginal-led solutions.
"Will children involved in these camps be paid for their labour, receive certifications for skills developed, accrue superannuation?" VALS CEO Nerita Waight asked.
"As these are the elements alongside therapeutic supports and interventions that would actually see opportunities for a better life, otherwise this is akin to slave labour."
Ms Waight, a strident critic of several Labor policies focusing on youth justice, said she was "disappointed but not surprised" by the Liberals' announcement.
"I am yet again confronted by a political party that does not understand child development, the impact of trauma, and that you cannot punish children into submission," she said.
The announcement comes a week after Labor, which has faced accusations of being weak on crime despite introducing several bail and youth offender policies, gave a pre-election commitment to have youth offenders pulled from the community and placed in a "tough love" rehabilitation program.
As part of the program, participants will be required to develop essential life skills, including cooking, cleaning and budgeting, Labor said. The rehabilitation program will be mandated through a court order rather than offered on a voluntary basis.
A post shared by VALS (@vicaboriginallegalservice)
Victorian Greens justice spokesperson Katherine Copsey slammed the two policy announcements, arguing both parties are "locked in a grotesque competition to see who can announce the cruellest headline and lock up the most children".
"Labor has had 12 years to tackle the poverty, disadvantage and systemic failures that push children into the justice system. Instead, it wants to spend hundreds of millions of dollars locking them up," she said.
"You cannot punish a child out of poverty, imprison them out of trauma, or give them a better future by putting them behind bars. Youth crime is a government failure."
However, shadow youth justice minister Renee Heath said Labor had failed to divert children and young people away from crime during its 12 years in government.
"It's time for a new approach," she said.
"Our bootcamps will give young offenders structure, discipline and practical skills while making it clear that their actions have consequences. We will give young Victorians the tools to turn their lives around, but we will never put the safety of the community second."